Zammit-Borda_2015.PDF (420.78 kB)
Appraisal-Based and Flexible Approaches to External Precedent in International Criminal Law
journal contribution
posted on 2023-08-30, 16:46 authored by Aldo Zammit BordaThis article focuses on the approaches of international criminal judges to using external precedent, distinguishing between the appraisal-based and flexible approaches. On the one hand, the appraisal-based approach refers to uses of external judicial decisions which are preceded by an express legal appraisal. On the other hand, the flexible approach denotes a less stringent use of such decisions. It finds that, in a number of cases, international criminal judges have adopted a flexible approach to decisions and have assimilated them within the legal framework of the referring court or tribunal without the necessary adjustment. This may have important implications for the principle of legality and the fairness of the proceedings. The paper indicates that the adoption of either the appraisal-based or flexible approaches to external judicial decisions is not necessarily linked to the specific legal backgrounds of the judges involved, and different judges hailing from varying legal backgrounds have shifted between these approaches in different cases. This suggests that there is need for greater rigour in the judicial methodology for using external judicial decisions and, in particular, the importance of the appraisal-based approach to using such decisions, to ensure their the congruence with the legal framework of the referring court or tribunal.
History
Refereed
- Yes
Volume
28Issue number
3Page range
643-664Publication title
Leiden Journal of International LawISSN
1478-9698External DOI
Publisher
Cambridge University PressFile version
- Accepted version
Language
- eng
Official URL
Legacy posted date
2019-11-12Legacy creation date
2019-11-13Legacy Faculty/School/Department
ARCHIVED Faculty of Arts, Law & Social Sciences (until September 2018)Usage metrics
Categories
No categories selectedKeywords
Licence
Exports
RefWorks
BibTeX
Ref. manager
Endnote
DataCite
NLM
DC