The experience of critiquing published research: learning from the student and researcher perspective

Knowles, Judie and Gray, Morag A. (2011) The experience of critiquing published research: learning from the student and researcher perspective. Nurse Education in Practice, 11 (6). pp. 390-394. ISSN 1873-5223

Full text not available from this repository.
Official URL:


This paper commences with affirmation of the importance of research critique within academic programmes of study, and the context of this skill within the nursing profession. Judie (student) shares an experience from a Professional Doctorate in Education (EdD) assignment that involved selecting and critiquing a piece of published research. “The qualities of an effective mentor” (Gray and Smith, 2000) was critiqued using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP, 2006) framework. Morag was the researcher and co-author (Gray and Smith, 2000) and was subsequently contacted by Judie for the purposes of validating her critique assignment. On the tenth anniversary since publication of her PhD research findings Morag reflects on the original article in the light of Judie’s critique and shares evaluative comments. Some of the assignment critique is validated by Morag, whilst some of the evaluation demonstrates unreliability of critique shown by Judie. Discussion surrounding sufficiency of research critique through systematic examination of a published article, versus an original research report such as a thesis ensues. The student and researcher/author reveal their learning from this collaborative experience and conclude with recommendations for; setting critique assignments; authors publishing their research findings; and students undertaking critique assignments.

Item Type: Journal Article
Keywords: Critique, Mentorship, Research, CASP
Faculty: ARCHIVED Faculty of Health, Social Care & Education (until September 2018)
Depositing User: Repository Admin
Date Deposited: 08 Jul 2013 12:55
Last Modified: 09 Sep 2021 16:17

Actions (login required)

Edit Item Edit Item